parisar …………………………………………….परिसर

a forum of progressive students……………………………………………………………..प्रगतिशील छात्रों का मंच

SIMI Here, SIMI There, SIMI Everywhere

This SIMI litigation is an omnibus case in which the 100 plus accused are now always at hand to be implicated in future cases, Reports AJIT SAHI

ON HINDSIGHT, it wasn’t perhaps the best of ideas. In the most galling of attacks, terrorists had stormed Parliament just 14 days earlier and, for the while it lasted, the nation had held its breath in sheer horror. Undeniably, a group of radical-looking Muslims gathering so close after that crime would be vulnerable to police suspicion. But little could these 124 Muslims have imagined what was in store for them in the years to come when they gathered on December 27, 2001 at Gujarat’s port city of Surat.

A well-known Muslim organisation called the All-India Minority Educational Board had called participants from across India to attend the 8th Seminar on the “Constitutional Provisions for Minorities’ Educational Rights”. Its mandate was to discuss ways to harness constitutional provisions to help economically and educationally backward Muslims. The first topic of discussion was “The Role of Minority Education in Promotion of National Integration”. Also to be discussed were the “Contribution of Sir Saiyed [Founder of Aligarh Muslim University] in the Educational Field” and “Social Service and its Education in India”. The motley group included authors, teachers and scholars, as well as religious leaders. The meeting was to begin the next day and last two days.

All the 124 participants had gathered by the night of December 27 at a well-known cinema hall-turned-wedding venue in Surat called Rajshri Hall, also a favourite with the likes of Rotary Club. As they prepared to lie down on their beds, policemen came in and arrested them. The police seized a banner of the organisation, a few copies of the programme and the papers that some participants were to present, etc. It also claimed that it seized “unlawful material” such as SIMI receipt books.

The FIR alleged SIMI had called the meeting and the participants were hatching a conspiracy. SIMI had been banned three months ago, so it was easy to bring a host of charges of “unlawful activity” against them. It didn’t matter that nearly every one of them was much older than the upper age limit of 30 years for SIMI’s membership. The next day, a local judge packed off the 124 to police custody for 14 days. Later, they were sent to jail in judicial custody. Bail was denied. All hopes for bail died when the Sabarmati Express caught fire at Godhra on February 27, 2002, and the macabre killings of Muslims began in Gujarat.

ZIAUDDIN SIDDIQUI, the pharmacist from Aurangabad in neighbouring Maharashtra, is an accused in this case. He spent 11 months in the Surat jail. First, five people managed bail in October 2002. Then Siddiqui and 85 others got bail on November 20 that year. This bail order, by Gujarat High Court Judge DP Buch, was a scathing comment on the police case. It said: “It is not much in dispute that incriminating materials have not been seized from the personal search of the petitioners of this petition.”

Still, the court ordered every accused to appear at a Surat police station every Sunday. As all the accused, save five, were from outside Surat, they would have to travel to the city every week. The bail order said if a petitioner absented himself twice in a row from the trial court, then the bail “shall stand cancelled without any formal order of the Court”. Passports had to be surrendered. Over time, the accused have been exempted from visiting the police station. The Supreme Court later relaxed the condition on personal appearances at the trial and rejected automatic bail cancellation saying due process of law will have to be followed if bail already given has to be cancelled for some reason.

One of the witnesses in this case is the controversial Gujarat police officer, Narendra Amin — the man accused in Hyderabad of shooting dead the brother of Moutasim Billah (profiled on page 28) in October 2004 and is now lodged in a Gujarat jail, accused of killing in cold blood Kausar Bi, the wife of businessman Sohrabuddin, who himself was killed in a fake encounter.

Despite the fact that Rajshri Hall is one of the best-known venues for public gatherings in Surat, the police could find no independent witnesses to attest to the arrest and seizures. The defence has claimed in the trial court that the witnesses who did join the investigation are themselves accused in other cases registered in the same police station. The Surat police also wrote to police in other states seeking more information on all the other accused in the case.

In the case of Ziauddin Siddiqui (profiled on page 38) the Aurangabad police promptly wrote back saying, yes, he was indeed an “active SIMI member”. The Surat police offered that letter from the Aurangabad police to the trial court as clinching evidence that since Siddiqui was a SIMI member, and since he was a participant there, it was obvious that the Surat meeting was called by SIMI.

One of the accused is 46-yearold Mohammad Muslim, a civil construction contractor from Ahmedabad. “The police had been swarming around us since morning,” he recalled in an interview with TEHELKA in Ahmedabad. Muslim was never a member of SIMI. He spent nine months in three jails across Gujarat before getting bail.

Four of the accused were denied bail even by the High Court. They had to go all the way to the Supreme Court and could get bail only in February 2003. These include Atta-ur-rehman Kureshi of Saharanpur, the gentle septuagenarian (profiled on page 36). As Chairman of the host organisation, Kureshi is accused number one. Another accused is a professor of economics at Jodhpur University.

In 2005, High Court judge RP Dholakia ordered that the matter be expedited and the trial end in six months. The trial is still going on. Five of the eight witnesses have turned hostile. The police said the host organisation’s Delhi office was untraceable. As proof, they filed a report from a police sub-inspector, who they claimed went to Delhi for a day, sat in a taxi, hunted for the office, couldn’t find it, and came back. The report, interestingly, was filed on December 29 — barely two days after the arrests.

When “live” bombs were being diffused in Surat last week, police and intelligence agencies announced they were “keeping a close watch” on the five “SIMI activists from Surat who were arrested in December 2001”. •
From Tehelka Magazine, Vol 5, Issue 32, Dated Aug 16, 2008


September 25, 2008 - Posted by | articles

1 Comment »

  1. Well done, Mr. Sahi, or whatever your real may. Surely, this is what ISI like to call you. With Namak Haram bastards like you, who need parasite Indian Muslims anyway?

    Before, you ramble on complaining about India police and Justice system, did even you ask those SIMI bastards, that if SIMI is a truly peaceful organization, why don’t we see them protesting against bomb blasts??????????

    Why they are crying for those in their community who kill innocent people, but never offer a word of condolences to victim famies? SIMI is nowhere to be found then when it comes to protesting such activities, because their are the originator of them.

    Now a Muslim university wants to use government funds to offer legal aid to the accused in bombing. Wow. Well how about offering even a word of sympathy to those killed. One would ask, what does a university doing defending a woman charged with treason and terrorism????? Because it one their “brothers”. Whole Muslim stings with filth of loyalty to PAK and hate for India.

    Muslim leaders are suspiciously silent when it comes to correcting their own community. Even SIMI leader don’t want to investigate their own organization, you know just in case if it was true????

    All Muslims know is how to produce babies and plant bombs. They want to dominate India by creating more of their creatures.

    You might have read the recent evidence mentioned on the front pages for Times of India – surely not an agent of government. SIMI has been fully exposed for what it is – A ISI funded Namak Haram Muslim bastard organization, whose sole purpose to do harm to India.

    ISI can’t stand that while PAK is on the brink of collapse, India is sending a man to the moon. President Zadari is in New York with a begging bowl, as PAK is rapidly running out of cash and faces default on its debt. European Union conducting a meeting on how to prevent PAK being a failed state.

    But what the heck, Indian Muslims are truly worst kind of the humans. They want to enjoy Indian food, Indian luxuries and Indian lifestyle, but always supporting PAK in their heart. No matter what, Indian Muslims will NEVER will loyal to India.

    When I read your article, I didn’t know whether to cry or laugh. You seem VERY gulable and neive to be an reporter. One thing you are not is an objective reporter.

    Police will know the doors, because so many officers have been shot trying to approach them peacefully – Officer M.C. Chanda of police recently.

    Police will react immediately because these Muslim bastards know they are hunted and are on the move constantly. Time is of essence in cases like these.

    There is very well documented phenomenon that when a captive spends enough time with their, they began to sympathize with them. You, Mr. Sahi or whatever you or real name or religion is, appear to fallen in the same trap. Of-course they are going to exhibit only their best side. Did you really think that SIMI would really admit their evil acts.

    Well, I know making a living in India can be hard, especially when you are running a magzine or reporting for one. So many bills and commitments. Creditors hounding you day or night? So a hefty payment from ISI is enough to carry you for few months, enough time to write part II of your article for another payment and get the creditors off your back for a while.

    Keep this phrase of work and don’t worry about enjoying a nice a standard of living. ISI has plenty of fake Indian notes for traitors like you to distribute.

    Burn in Hell Mr. Sahi, for being such a traitor – sham on you and your mother who gave birth to you.

    P.S. Just when I am writing this, news came that there is bombing in Surat. no doubt work of your “Muslim” brothers. But don’t you worry, and check you mail for a check from ISI.

    How do you sleep at night and look at yourself in the mirror Mr. Sahi?????????????????????

    Comment by SonofMotherIndia | September 28, 2008

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s